(1947) “Chaplin’s changed.
Have you?” (re-release
tagline) Suddenly, the screen’s
most beloved character
changed: gone were the
Tramp’s canal boat shoes,
shabby genteel attire, the
black curly hair, the oft-tipped
derby, the twirling cane, the
mustache square, the
melancholy, shy-around-women
vagabond. Now he’s a fastidious, elegantly attired
seeming commercial traveler who’s obviously a devil
with the ladies; but who, in fact, supports a family by
marrying multiple women and then despatching them
for their money. Based on an idea suggested by Orson
Welles, himself inspired by the real-life serial killer
Landru, Chaplin’s “Comedy of Murders” — its original
title — ranges in mood from Hitchcockian suspense
to knock-down, drag-out farce, especially with
outrageously vulgar nouveau riche lottery winner and
impossible-to-whack Martha Raye, in a scene-stealing
performance as “the most vulgar woman ever
created, chattering away with her mouth full of
croissant and laughing not like one drain but ten”
(Geoff Brown) — a takeoff on An American Tragedy’s
drowning turns into a Chaplinian dunking. A theme
and character of remarkable complexity, which
garnered reviews ranging from personal attacks on
the supposed Communist sympathizer, to measured
judgments on character and plot inconsistencies,
to James Agee’s impassioned three-part
counterblast to the critics in The Nation. “Only Chaplin would have had the audacity to find material for a moral fable in himself, in the stock market crash, in the depression, as well as in the rise of Mussolini and Hitler and the beginnings of World War II.” – Vincent Canby, New York Times. “Among the great works of this century. . . Chaplin’s performance is the best piece of playing I have seen: [with a] dozen or so close-ups each like the notes of a slow, magnificent, and terrifying song, which the rest of the film serves as an accompaniment. Chaplin’s theme, the greatest that he has yet undertaken, is the bare problem of surviving at all in such a world as this.” – James Agee. Approx. 123 min.
A FILM DESK RELEASE.